Wow sounds as if I wrote this about our Breakaway cruise western Caribbean, most of your review was spot on to our cruise , Ocean Blue best food. I wanted a Ceaser Salad not on the menu but our waitress got me one as with no sugar free dessert she got me one . , . We ate at Cagneys a few nights earlier it was ok the service was excellent the sides and salad excellence, my porterhouse steak was ok would say was maybe 1/2 inch thick cooked medium rare as I ordered but it wasn’t the quality of I would say I only ate 1.2 of it not normal for me . . The steak my mother in law had at ocean blue was excellent, , everything else you mentioned was very similar to our experience .we were a group of 65 family and a few friends celebrating mother in law’s 92 birthday. One thing to add the $9.95 phone app was pretty much worthless if you don’t have an apple phone. Most time it wasn’t working.