Was on the leg to Barcelona, also loved the Rock Room band. The Billboard pair was ok, but the better of the two (Ivy) got off when we did as her contract was up. Hopefully her replacement is as good.
Service was mostly good, but sometimes it was difficult to flag a waiter down for drinks in the pool areas.
Food was always great, and most days at lunch there was a Lido station with completely different options for the day: dim sum, Dutch/German meats and sauerkraut, Portuguese charcuterie...
Agree on the smoking being annoying- why the smokers area in the casino is located in the main walking path confounds me
It was a great crossing!