Oh that is really interesting! I will follow the replies with interest. What I will say is we cruised several older Princess ships and none gave us the crummy trip we had on Caribbean. I think it has a really poor design for one thing…I’ve been on ships with more capacity yet never felt so crowded with a lack of personal spaces as I did on CB. We witnessed what looked like a dump of some type of oily substance out in the wake on no less than three occasions. The whole thing was subpar compared to what we were used to on the line, though the food was fine and service very good across the board. It’s just hard to get past that cramped feeling and those unfortunate, pervasive toilet smells.
Our first Princess cruise was on the Grand, which we dearly loved, and we were moored along side the CB in, I believe) Antigua. One of the “elder statesmen” supervisors in the Horizon Court had stopped by our table for a chat when he gestured over at the CB and sniffed, “THAT is nothing more than a floating hotel. THIS (indicating Grand) is a real ship.” I’ve never forgotten that.