I have been writing cruise reviews for the past 40 years…with a concentration on food since that is my field of expertise. To me it boils down to hearing from pax who don’t know good food, those who don’t want to be judgmental, and those who really do know quality. You have to sift through the information and make your own decision. I’ve also noticed that most reviews really don’t go into the food to any extent. Since a cruise is made up of eating morning noon and night this makes no sense to me. IMO good food is not subjective it’s the mediocre food that is subjective.