we were on Liberty a few weeks ago. If people are looking for perfection, keep looking. For sure, if you look hard enough you will find some things that are old, faded, maybe needing to be replaced. Yes, the big screen at the pool is out of order and the tv's in the room wasn't worth watching. These didn't bother me . Saying that, we had a great time. Good food, good service. Beds were comfortable, at least the one we had. Liberty has one water slide no other Royal ship has, The Tidal Wave. I went on it numerous times with my 8 year old granddaughter. It was awesome. It has been years since since we have been on either Freedom or Indy , so I can't comment on those ships.