Ducky22

We have always gone with Cozumel H2O in Cozumel. They have been fantastic. Unfortunately they are a boat dive outfit, so not the most helpful information. You could always email them about renting tanks or ask them about doing a check to make sure they include time / opportunity to do one if you change your mind and do the boat thing. Sorry I can't be of more help.

I have also gone with Pro Divers at St. Kitts and had a lovely time. They took us to an area with an underwater vent, and another area with a lot of crusing sharks. Was a great time. As for Tortola, I've only been there once, but Blue Water Divers BVI was excellent. I saw my first reef squids with them! I can't say which is better, honestly I would dive both 😁

I'm fairly sure there are other operators in Nassau. Last time we were there in Nov 2018 we went with Bahama Divers - https://www.betterinbahamas.com/scuba-diving/private-2-tank-dive-wreck-reef-all-inclusive/ They were decent, but the water was surprisingly chilly at that time of year. They are located just across from Atlantis more or less, so just down the road from the usual port location. I agree with bruzin though, the diving is pretty meh on the north side from what I've seen. I've never been in Nassau long enough to head over to Stuart Cove's though so I don't really know what the more southerly side would be like.

What's the new Cozumel option? We've always gone with Cozumel H2O, but always nice to have a backup if they are full....