We have been on the PG 3x , most recently 9/23. We love everything about the PG, but …but….Windstar is making it very attractive with pricing. So, we have booked an 11 day in mid-August. We will do our own air , hotel and transfers as we have done in the past. We were on the Star Pride, similar to Star Breeze and loved the cabins , the double sinks and walk in closet and the variety of dining experiences. Windstar has been on FP for 35 years and knows immersion. I know the only thing I will miss is the balcony - I just can’t bring myself to pay up for a Juliette balcony - and we rarely spend time outside except once in a awhile for early breakfast - we are off the boat early and by the time we are back it’s getting ready for the evening . It will be interesting to see the comparison- can’t wait to start seeing reviews