Upscale lines

I just realized that I made a reply to a year and half old post. I'm used to HAL and others that post pages per day.

Would someone from this board give me their impressions from cruising various upscale lines.

Looking for 2005 cruise.

The three lines I would consider upscale aer Silverseas, Seabourn, and Raddisson. IMHO, Crystal and Celebrity are slightly lower because of things like 2 dinner seatings, tipping, and no compilmentry beverages. We have been on all 3, and I hve some trip stories written. My e-mail address is highlandpark@mindspring.com is you would like to read them.