Nationwide Luxury Cruise or HTH Trip Protector Classic

I have my insurance choices down to these 2 companies. HTH gives slightly more in medical and is $20 cheaper. Has anyone put in a claim on either plan? Which do you recommend! TIA
Expand Signature
Collapse Signature
10/1992 Carnival Festivale
05/1999 Royal Caribbean Sovereign of the Seas
08/2004 Norwegian Crown
05/2006 Disney Wonder
04/2008 Disney Magic
07/2010 Carnival Glory
08/2011 Disney Wonder
08/2013 Carnival Ecstasy
08/2015 Carnival Victory
08/2016 Carnival Sensation
06/2017 Carnival Sensation
08/2018 Carnival Magic