Mike R 2018 Posted January 16, 2018 #2826 Share Posted January 16, 2018 (edited) DECK - Sky (10) CABIN # - 1210 Silhouette CLASS - C1 STARBOARD OR PORT SIDE - Aft BED NEAR - Balcony QUIET CABIN - Very Quiet BALCONY VIEW - 180 Degrees Aft - Great BALCONY SIZE - Largest Aft Concierge Balcony on Deck 10 WAS WIND A PROBLEM - No SOOT PROBLEM - No soot at all on 7 day cruise. SPECIFIC PROBLEMS - None, but the cabin is starting to show it's age. OTHER COMMENTS - Long walk to the elevators. Room Attendant Tania was excellent. Edited January 16, 2018 by Mike R 2018 Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Kosh III Posted January 16, 2018 #2827 Share Posted January 16, 2018 (edited) SHIP: Reflection CABIN #: 2166 DECK #: 12 CLASS: Concierge AREA: Middle on hump, near elevators; a plus for us as it gave easy access to our frequent spots. BED NEAR: Balcony QUIET?: Yes BALCONY VIEW: Yes, excellent. BALCONY SIZE: Huge due to being on the hump. Loved it. WIND A PROBLEM?: No SOOT A PROBLEM?: No PROBLEMS/COMMENTS: Our first Celebrity cruise, priors were Carnival and RCI. We definitely like Celebrity better, especially as we got great deals. We have two more Celebrity cruises booked now. We loved the Sunset bar at the top aft. Edited January 16, 2018 by Kosh III Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Jlhalldc Posted January 22, 2018 #2828 Share Posted January 22, 2018 Celebrity Eclipse Sky Suite 2123 SHIP: Eclipse CABIN #: 2123 DECK #: 12 CLASS: Sky Suite AREA: Aft BED NEAR: Bathroom QUIET?: Yes; we were concerned because it's beneath Ocean View Cafe but the carpeting successfully muffled any noise. BALCONY VIEW: Overhang is close but protects against sun or rain (perfect for reading or a glass of port before bed). The hump obstructs the view of the front of the ship and outcropping obstructs the view of the aft so one can feel a bit boxed in. Glad we were in the middle. BALCONY SIZE: Nice size; two adjustable chairs with foot stools and full sized table. WIND A PROBLEM?: No. SOOT A PROBLEM?: No. PROBLEMS/COMMENTS: The view is a bit confining, but not bad. We were relieved noise from overhead wasn't a problem. Easy access to pool and Ocean View Cafe. Engine vibration was noticeable when travelling fast but it wasn't a problem for us. Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
vulcan1971 Posted January 23, 2018 #2829 Share Posted January 23, 2018 Celebrity Silhouette Sunset Veranda 6310 SHIP: Silhouette CABIN #: 6310 DECK #: 6 CLASS: SV AREA: Aft BED NEAR: Bathroom QUIET?: Yes, very quiet. No noise from the hallway, or from surrounding neighbors. BALCONY VIEW: View from this balcony over the aft of the ship is amazing. I now understand why this is called a "sunset veranda". A great view in general, be it the wake of the ship or looking out from the ship. BALCONY SIZE: Two adjustable chairs and a table. Size of this aft balcony is smaller than other surrounding balconies. WIND A PROBLEM?: No. SOOT A PROBLEM?: No. PROBLEMS/COMMENTS: None. Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
jenZ Posted January 23, 2018 #2830 Share Posted January 23, 2018 Delete. Pressed wrong button! Sent from my iPhone using Forums Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
rkreilly Posted January 26, 2018 #2831 Share Posted January 26, 2018 THANK YOU SO MUCH! This is a wonderful resource! Cabin reports on this thread have been compiled into a spreadsheet that can be read online or downloaded to Excel for further review and research. The date of the spreadsheet reflects the last update. Thanks for your contribution. Google Spreadsheet Please use this format for posting your cabin reviews. Feel free to add photos or links to photos also. SHIP: CABIN #: DECK #: CLASS: AREA: BED NEAR: QUIET?: BALCONY VIEW: BALCONY SIZE: WIND A PROBLEM?: SOOT A PROBLEM?: PROBLEMS/COMMENTS: Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Cruise a holic Posted January 26, 2018 #2832 Share Posted January 26, 2018 SHIP: Eclipse CABIN #: 1112 DECK #: 10 CLASS: Celebrity Suite AREA: Midship BED NEAR: separate bedroom QUIET?: yes BALCONY VIEW: midship BALCONY SIZE: oversized WIND A PROBLEM?:no SOOT A PROBLEM?:no PROBLEMS/COMMENTS: None- loved the storage, walk in closet and extra space. Enjoyed separate living room. Smaller then the M class Celebrity suites- would book again for the right price. Near elevator, great location on Library floor. Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
CarolynAustralia Posted January 29, 2018 #2833 Share Posted January 29, 2018 SHIP: Solstice CABIN #: 3103 DECK #: 3 CLASS: AREA: Near Solstice Theatre but no noise BED NEAR: Oceanview QUIET?: Very Quiet BALCONY VIEW: N/A BALCONY SIZE: N/A WIND A PROBLEM?: No SOOT A PROBLEM?: No PROBLEMS/COMMENTS: This room and bathroom is huge. Incredibly quiet. Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
WhisperingLemur Posted January 31, 2018 #2834 Share Posted January 31, 2018 SHIP: Reflection CABIN #: 7243 DECK #: 7 CLASS: 1A AREA: Midship BED NEAR: Balcony QUIET?: Yes BALCONY VIEW: Excellent. Down and Out. BALCONY SIZE: One of the larger hump balconies WIND A PROBLEM?: No SOOT A PROBLEM?: No PROBLEMS/COMMENTS: We loved it. Loved the "hump" balcony. Loved the location near the elevator but not noisy. It was super convenient. Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Pushkin Posted February 6, 2018 #2835 Share Posted February 6, 2018 SHIP: Silhouette CABIN #: 3123 DECK #: 3 CLASS: Oceanview AREA: Midship BED NEAR: window QUIET?: yes BALCONY VIEW: N/A BALCONY SIZE: N/A WIND A PROBLEM?: N/A SOOT A PROBLEM?: N/A PROBLEMS/COMMENTS: None- Our last few cruises we have sailed in ocean views. We find we do not use the balcony enough to justify the higher cost. Deck 3- just down from Customer Relations, is a very convenient spot. Turn the other way and you are at the theater. Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
queenie57 Posted February 10, 2018 #2836 Share Posted February 10, 2018 SHIP: Equinox CABIN #: 9378 DECK #: 9 CLASS: C1 AREA: starboard, aft-facing BED NEAR: balcony QUIET?: yes BALCONY VIEW: amazing view of wake BALCONY SIZE: wider than those on either side of us by about 3 feet WIND A PROBLEM?: no SOOT A PROBLEM?: no PROBLEMS/COMMENTS: very quiet room. I'd choose it again in a heartbeat. Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
cruising in mn Posted February 11, 2018 #2837 Share Posted February 11, 2018 SHIP: Celebrity Equinox CABIN #: 1601 (Hump cabin) DECK #: 11 CLASS: Aqua (A1) AREA: Mid ship BED NEAR: Windows QUIET?: NO! BALCONY VIEW: Unobstructed BALCONY SIZE: HUGE! Biggest I've ever had WIND A PROBLEM?: No SOOT A PROBLEMGE?: No PROBLEMS/COMMENTS: Very close to elevators, and directly below main pool area. Every night there was a party above, that started roughly 10:45 pm, and you could hear every word. Lots of dragging of chairs. Extremely noisy. Wouldnt get this room, even though its a hump room again, as it kept us awake most nights. Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
PENNST66 Posted February 20, 2018 #2838 Share Posted February 20, 2018 SHIP: Eclipse CABIN #: 6307 DECK #: 6 CLASS: Sunset Veranda AREA: Aft BED NEAR: Balcony QUIET?: yes BALCONY VIEW: Aft BALCONY SIZE: Standard WIND A PROBLEM?:no SOOT A PROBLEM?:no PROBLEMS/COMMENTS: Could hear and feel vibrations when changing speeds or docking! Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Iamthesea Posted February 21, 2018 #2839 Share Posted February 21, 2018 SOLSTICE SHIP: Solstice CABIN #: 1601 DECK (#): 11 CLASS: AQ1 AREA: Mid-ship Port side - on hump BED NEAR: (Bath/Balcony) - Balcony QUIET?: Mostly BALCONY VIEW: BALCONY SIZE: Over-sized - Largest of the hump balconies. WIND A PROBLEM?: Not really - Only on cooler days at sea SOOT A PROBLEM?: No PROBLEMS/COMMENTS: Read lot's of reviews about noise from above, noise from industrial fan, noise from deck parties, AQ Cafe ice machine (not even below that!), noise from hallway closets and service doors, etc. However, other than an occasional odd noise here and there, we were not bothered. I am noise sensitive, so that is saying a lot! Maybe because we sleep with a white noise machine helped. We could hear faint music from the pool deck during sea days. I think the industrial fan noise must have drowned out most of it. :) We liked the fan noise. Did not notice a fan noise inside the stateroom as others have commented. Honestly, we were out and about so much that perhaps we missed hearing some noises. To us, the most offending noise came from our neighbors slamming their door. We are trying 1606 on the Eclipse in May. Will report back on that stateroom, as well. Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
daisy-mae Posted February 23, 2018 #2840 Share Posted February 23, 2018 SHIP: Reflection CABIN #: 8333 DECK #: 8 CLASS: Deluxe Veranda AREA: Aft BED NEAR: Bathroom QUIET?: Yes BALCONY VIEW: overlooks Blu Dining Room when looking down, clear view straight ahead, above smoking area on Deck 5 but no issues BALCONY SIZE: large enough for two chairs and a table WIND A PROBLEM?: No SOOT A PROBLEM?: No PROBLEMS/COMMENTS: aft cabin, almost at the very end of the hallway - a bit of a hike to the elevators Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
RustyR1 Posted February 24, 2018 #2841 Share Posted February 24, 2018 SHIP: Eclipse CABIN #: 2122 DECK #: 12 CLASS: Sky Suite (S2) AREA: Aft, Starboard BED NEAR: Bath QUIET?: Yes BALCONY VIEW: Good BALCONY SIZE: Half-again as wide as standard WIND A PROBLEM?: No SOOT A PROBLEM?: No PROBLEMS/COMMENTS: Nice size cabin with lots of closet and drawer space. Only 3 electrical outlets; 2 US and 1 Euro. Cabin was quiet, but I think if you move further aft you may get noise because you'll be under the main serving area of the Oceanview Cafe. Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
njaloha Posted February 24, 2018 #2842 Share Posted February 24, 2018 (edited) SHIP: Silhouette CABIN #: 1202 DECK #: 10 CLASS: S1 sky suite AREA: Aft Starboard BED NEAR: Balcony QUIET?: Yes BALCONY VIEW: of wake but side view obstructed by large scaffolding for washing BALCONY SIZE: large enough for 2 chairs, 2 ottomans and large table WIND A PROBLEM?: No SOOT A PROBLEM?: YES!!!!! Not only is soot a problem but the wind carried the stack exhaust down onto me while on the balcony and created burning sensation in my nose. Not what I expected from an aft balcony experience. The soot issue was the worst on the last morning when I decided to check out the view of the sunrise after we had docked in Ft Lauderdale. It was dark and I had no idea the deck was covered in soot. I found out later when after the sun rose, I opened the slider to step out and stopped short when I looked down and saw how much soot there was. Our balcony was only cleaned once, while in St Thomas and the cleaning crew came through our cabin to access all balconies. AS far as I can tell that equipment never moved, btw. PROBLEMS/COMMENTS: Cabin was exceptionally quiet and difficult to find since it's behind an unmarked door. Also, please note that I'm not prone to seasickness, stayed in a cabin on deck 11 forward for a difficult 3 days from Bayonne to the Caribbean in January with no problems, but I found the deck 10 AFT location troublesome. I solved it with mind control! and michael's club. Seriously, went down and mid ship and I was fine. Would take a lot to book this cabin for me. Also, this part of the ship - starboard aft hallway - was near the crew staircase from galley areas on decks 3-5. Every day, but the worst was at night after dinner, we could smell strong cooking smells in the corridor. Once you've been to Murano, you know what the lobster speciality smells like and that's what filled the hall. Or the smell of grilling steak (from Lawn Club?). Interesting observation though and unexpected. Edited February 24, 2018 by njaloha more info Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
jaydublax Posted February 25, 2018 #2843 Share Posted February 25, 2018 SHIP: Silhouette CABIN #: 1606 DECK #: 11 CLASS: AquaClass AREA: Mid-Ship BED NEAR: Bathroom QUIET?: Yes, however, in the morning you could hear deck chairs being set up around 7am and you could hear the deck leaky music. You could hear it but it certainly didn’t bother us. It was not excessive. BALCONY VIEW: on the forward side of the hump so you could see out and forward but not back. BALCONY SIZE: extra large balcony! Two chairs, foot stools and a table. Note that the deck above hangs out so this balcony and room got a lot less light but the la g size made up for it. WIND A PROBLEM?: No SOOT A PROBLEM?: No PROBLEMS/COMMENTS: loved the location just off the midship elevators so super quick to get anywhere in the ship. One day with the way the ind was blowing we got a little smoke exhaust smell but no soot. Note that there is an air handler above outside, but on sea days it just sounded like the water. Sent from my iPad using Forums Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Fogfog Posted February 26, 2018 #2844 Share Posted February 26, 2018 SHIP: Silhouette CABIN #: 9380 DECK #: 9 AFT facing balcony CLASS: Concierge AREA: AFT balcony. Muster station D3 (Tuscan grill) BED NEAR: Balcony QUIET?: yes. BALCONY VIEW: AFT/wake BALCONY SIZE: normal. 2 chairs, 2 footstools, 1 table WIND A PROBLEM?: no SOOT A PROBLEM?: no PROBLEMS/COMMENTS: Typical cabin. No outlet near the bed--CPAP users bring extension cord. Last aft/starboard cabin before the door/anti room for the suite and adjoining cabin on the aft/star/corner. So with that suite/ante-room door closed, its a very quiet spot. The only people coming to this local are your neighbors in 9382, the suite guests and room stewards. Only "noise" was one day --someone in that suite/adjoining aft with the sliding closet doors. Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
snow bunny Posted March 4, 2018 #2845 Share Posted March 4, 2018 SHIP: Reflection CABIN #: 7305 DECK #: Sunrise CLASS: 2B AREA: Port side aft BED NEAR: Bathroom QUIET?: Yes, other than neighbor slamming door BALCONY VIEW: Port side, slight obstruction down BALCONY SIZE: Standard WIND A PROBLEM?: No SOOT A PROBLEM?: No PROBLEMS/COMMENTS: Slightly more shade provided on balcony due to having an angled overhang above. Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Tommy3putts Posted March 4, 2018 #2846 Share Posted March 4, 2018 SHIP: Equinox CABIN #: 1605 DECK #: 11 CLASS: A2 AREA: Port side mid BED NEAR: Balcony QUIET?: Yes. Under the pool deck never any noise from above BALCONY VIEW: Port side, great view BALCONY SIZE: Oversized. On the bump out WIND A PROBLEM?: No SOOT A PROBLEM?: No PROBLEMS/COMMENTS: Second time we’ve been in a 1605 Aqua class cabin (first on Reflection). We love this cabin primarily for the balcony. Highly recommended. Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
cruisin lady ca Posted March 4, 2018 #2847 Share Posted March 4, 2018 SHIP: Silhouette CABIN #: 9292 DECK #: 9 CLASS: 1A AREA: starboard near mid-ship elevators - aft facing angled balcony on hump BED NEAR: Balcony QUIET?: yes. BALCONY VIEW: clear view of starboard side and aft BALCONY SIZE: oversized (largest of angled cabins on hump). 2 chairs, 1 round table WIND A PROBLEM?: no SOOT A PROBLEM?: no PROBLEMS/COMMENTS: Very convenient location to mid-ship elevators and stairs. Easy to walk up to pool deck, and down to decks 3 (Customer Relations) , 4 (Opus main dining room and Martini Bar), and 5 (Cafe al Bacio). Quiet cabin. No noise from elevators. Would book this cabin again. Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
mfan Posted March 17, 2018 #2848 Share Posted March 17, 2018 Thanks for maintaining this spreadsheet. One suggestion, please freeze the first row to keep the header will remain visible as users scroll down the page. You can do that by selecting, View / Freeze / 1 row, from the menu. We'll be going on the Reflection in July. Our cabin is 1079, which is not on this list. I'll for sure send a review after I get back (or while I'm onboard if I can remember, lol). Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
jkturner Posted March 17, 2018 #2849 Share Posted March 17, 2018 SHIP: SOLSTICE CABIN #: 8322 DECK #: 8 CLASS: 1C AREA: AFT BED NEAR: Door QUIET?: yes most of the time BALCONY VIEW: UNOBSTRUCTED BALCONY SIZE: WIND A PROBLEM?:NO SOOT A PROBLEM?:NO PROBLEMS/COMMENTS: there is a wall cupboard in the hallway outside so sometimes the opening and shutting of this by crew can be noisy Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
teltrainer Posted March 18, 2018 #2850 Share Posted March 18, 2018 SHIP: Eclipse CABIN #: 8281 DECK #: 8 CLASS: S AREA: BED NEAR: Balcony QUIET?: not when stewards work. their closet is right outside. Door banging morning and night. Would not book again. BALCONY VIEW: angled view aft and straight out. Lovely! BALCONY SIZE: oversized. No footstools since not concierge cabin. Brought inflatables ones and pump worked great WIND A PROBLEM?: no SOOT A PROBLEM?:no PROBLEMS. Just steward room noise due to closet right outside door Sent from my iPhone using Forums Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Recommended Posts
Please sign in to comment
You will be able to leave a comment after signing in
Sign In Now