Snorkeling recommendations

[1153rsmith]

We are cruising to St. Thomas in May 2019.  We have snorkeled at Sapphire Beach and have also done a Champagne Catamaran snorkel to St. John before.  

 

We didn't see a lot of fish at St. John and are looking for recommendations for this trip where we would be able to see a better selection of fish.  

We are sailing Carnival so are open to either a ship excursion or an independent one.

 

Any recommendations?

[Sheffie]

We saw LOTS of fish by the island on Cinnamon  Bay on St. John. My daughter said it was better than what she has seen in Hawaii!