Who has the better kids club?

[JonesCruiser1978]

Which kids club do you prefer for a 10 year old?  Carnival or Royal?

[jbethel11]

1 minute ago, JonesCruiser1978 said:

Which kids club do you prefer for a 10 year old?  Carnival or Royal?

Carnival without a doubt. 

[RSLeesburg]

Have never been on Carnival, but have been on many RCI ships - and will add this.  The Adventure Ocean experience on Oasis class ship is drastically different than what you would get on Vision class ship.  Our son will be 10 on our next cruise, but he has been going to AO since he was three, and he loves the club.  Although to be fair, I am sure he would equally love the clubs on Disney, NCL, or Carnival too!  

[Stacie.]

We've done both Carnival and RCI and hands down my kids prefer Carnival.

[tinkr2]

My Kids loved all of them. Depends on the counselor and what kids are there. My grown kids, daughter would say Holland bc she met her boyfriend of 5 years there. Son would probably say Carnival bc he chatted with the same group for years and even met up with one family when they came to Orlando. My granddaughter really liked us but had a good time on Royal and NCL. She will try Carnival Horizon next month.

[courtlynndear]

I think RC is better for tots and Carnival is better for older kids. Per my reading/research.