Luminae vs Specialty Dining

[Gracie115]

On 6/12/2020 at 10:27 AM, Cruise a holic said:

We really enjoy the lawn club grill!  We go there multiple times during our Caribbean cruise

if we are in a royal suite or we have the unlimited dining package great for

dinner or if opened for lunch   Luminae cannot 

compare!

We enjoyed the LCG the first couple times but the last 2 it was very "ho-hum"  and the service nowhere near as good as we had had previously.  Luminae's service far superior...…  that's why we all have choices.....  hopefully we will be on the Reflection next April and "may" try it again because one of our group loves steak, but Luminae wins out every time for us.

[Cruise a holic]

45 minutes ago, Gracie115 said:

We enjoyed the LCG the first couple times but the last 2 it was very "ho-hum"  and the service nowhere near as good as we had had previously.  Luminae's service far superior...…  that's why we all have choices.....  hopefully we will be on the Reflection next April and "may" try it again because one of our group loves steak, but Luminae wins out every time for us.

Never had a bad experience on the Silly or Reflection. Steak and chops, Shish Kebobs excellent, individual pizza's a real treat.  We do not eat Lobster mac and cheese but many said great!  The salad bar was great- probably will not be available in the future, perhaps individual salad's will be offered.  And the warm chocolate chip cookie with vanilla ice cream wonderful.  Try again.  Steak so much better then luminae.  

 

Certainly worth a try- 

[Gracie115]

2 minutes ago, Cruise a holic said:

Never had a bad experience on the Silly or Reflection. Steak and chops, Shish Kebobs excellent, individual pizza's a real treat.  We do not eat Lobster mac and cheese but many said great!  The salad bar was great- probably will not be available in the future, perhaps individual salad's will be offered.  And the warm chocolate chip cookie with vanilla ice cream wonderful.  Try again.  Steak so much better then luminae.  

 

Certainly worth a try- 

 

 

Glad you enjoy it, and we may try again.  I have no doubt the steak is better than Luminae's but not being a huge beef eater that's not a major factor for me.  It's nice to have choices!!!  

[chemmo]

We are not the biggest Luminae fans but our criticism has always been about menu never service...However, we don’t want to dine in the same restaurant every night...We like variety of ambiance as well as variety of menu.

 

We prefer S class over M class because of the additional dining choices and when we cruised Reflection the addition of Lawn Grill and The Porch were appreciated...One of the bonus’s to us of booking a RS or a PH is that you can visit a speciality without feeling the need to get your ‘money’s worth’ by eating every course! 

 

Totally agree with Gracie115, “It’s nice to have choices”...

[Cruise a holic]

1 hour ago, Gracie115 said:

 

 

Glad you enjoy it, and we may try again.  I have no doubt the steak is better than Luminae's but not being a huge beef eater that's not a major factor for me.  It's nice to have choices!!!  

Do it!  I enjoy the lamb chops and shrimp and scallops kebab

[Gracie115]

1 hour ago, Cruise a holic said:

Do it!  I enjoy the lamb chops and shrimp and scallops kebab

The lamb chops may get me there!!!😁 Didn't know that was on the menu!

[Cruise a holic]

They are (were) baby lamb chops and delicious!  But you need 6 if you aren't ordering any other meat or fish.  Great with a veggie shish kebob!  Making myself hungry!  Unfortunately I will be on the Equinox next with no Lawn club grill.