St. John Honeymoon Beach Sail/Snorkel v. Turtle Bay Sail/Snorkel

[hiccups]

We're looking at two snorkeling excursions on our upcoming Celebrity cruise.  One is the "St. John Half Day Champagne Catamaran Sail Beach And Snorkel" which goes to Honeymoon Beach, and the other is the "Turtle Bay Sail and Snorkel Adventure."  My husband wants Turtle Bay, but I'm leaning towards Hooneymoon Beach.  I should have listened when he told me earlier to book whatever I wanted, but I wanted his input so he wouldn't blame me if the excursion wasn't any good 😄

It looks like the Turtle Bay excusion snorkeling is done from the catamaran, but I can't tell if the Honeymoon Beach excursion is snorkeling from the catamaran or the beach.  I would probably go with Turtle Bay if the snorkeling on the other excursion is only from the beach.

Does anyone have any input on either excursion, or if one location is better than the other for snorkeling?