I purchased it before prices went up for our upcoming 14 day Hawaii cruise. That 14 day price tag is a tough pill to swallow (tho we did have some OBC to offset)
We ALWAYS get the "all-inclusive" plan on NCL/Princess/Celebrity so not accustomed to paying out of pocket--ouch!
It is about $65/day including gratuity, so approx. $52/day cost each.
I KNOW DH will get his moneys worth & then some...mostly beer but he will move more towards frozen cocktails as the cruise goes on.
I am looking at true cost of drink package & drinks.
You will pay the gratuity irregardless whether you pay for the package or pay for the drinks.
Oh, trust me, your reasoning is what gave me pause...
BUT if it is a break even or even CLOSE for me, it's worth it--it's ALWAYS a good value for DH😆