DWIN1050

I have cruised on Disney, HAL, Carnival, Celebrity, and RCL. I have to say that Disney was the most disappointing. I think each line have certain foods they do well. Carnival does beef better than most. HAL does the unusual very well. We had a tenderloin of venison that was one of the best meals I have ever had. Their fish is also well prepared but can't say they do beef that well. I also liked their buffet. I enjoyed the food on RCL and Celebrity but nothing stands out in my mind for either except sitting at the Captain's table on RCL. I am looking forward to BLU on Celebrity in August.

We have to decide by Wednesday whether to take the Western Caribbean cruise on the Legend on 10/05/08 or 10/12/08. This will be our first Carnival and first Caribbean cruise, we have done TA's. We would prefer a date that is not during a school holiday. We have a hold on cabin 7190 with extended balcony - do these have lounge chairs? We are especially interested in excursions to Mayan ruins, which port has the best? Would appreciate any input, thanks.

cstory3, I will be in the same cabin in September. If you would like a review of the room I will be happy to give you one.