Positivity for Celebrity - Who's with me?

[Bridge Maven]

This is just my opinion, but I find "us against them" threads, such as this one, much more offensive than any negative post I have read about a Celebrity cruise. Not only is it divisive, but it gives people the idea that if you are not a Celebrity cheerleader you will be shunned on cruise critic. What is the purpose of reading cruise reviews if they only come from people who think that every cruise is perfect. That is what cruise line brochures are for!

[Ma Bell]

Almost everyone who has posted on this thread has made a point to say that they appreciate hearing the positive and negative experiences people have. The discussion is about those posts that are completely negative and downright unreasonable. Where would you get the idea it's an "us against them" mentality?