Enchantment JS 8150 or 8152

[vavasmom]

We just got off the EN yesterday (great 6 night cruise).

 

My initial plans for an August vacation are not working out so I am considering booking a cruise instead. We were in 8136 which was very noisy with the metal chairs and tables being dragged across the floor until 2am many nights. We also had lots of running/heavy walking/carts on the tile. It was worse than being under the cantilevered hot tubs on Freedom (yes I have stayed in on of those GS) or the GS under the Windjammer on the EN).

 

Looking at the remaining JS these seem to have the most potential to not have the Solarium furniture issue. Has anyone stayed in either of these (the only review I could find was from 2009 that said 8152 was noisy from the pantry). Someone also said 8150 had a pole; others said it did not (no one in these threads appeared to have stayed in the room).

 

Thanks in advance

[vavasmom]

Before anyone points out what I just realized - I stayed in 8150 last year when RCCL moved us at the last minute - so I know the answer to my own question.

 

I currently feel like an idiot - we were actually initially booked in more forward JS but agreed to move at the last minute to allow a family group to all be together.