help me pick an excursion!!

[bp traveler]

We will be in Belieze for the first time ever and need help with a shore excursion.

 

Coral Breeze told me they are not doing tours on Dec 25th the day we are in port so they are out.

 

The Cruise ship is offering Banister Island - for $40 for 4 hours

 

I have also contacted another provider Eco Tours to go to Goff's Caye for for snorkeling for 1 hours and beach time for 2 hours it is $45 per person. We have a senior with us who will not snorkel, I believe she can hang back at the beach (??) while we snorkel.

 

What would you do? Is Bannister Island nice or is Goff's Caye better, less people, etc?

 

thanks