Anyone have experience with NCL Haven *and* MSC Yacht Club? Or...

[mom2sons]

Cross-posting this on the MSC thread for additional responses

 

Anyone know where I can find a side by side comparison of the benefits?

 

We are looking at either MSC Divina or the NCL Epic. In trying to compare the two for price versus value it seems difficult to decide who has the better program. I started out making a spreadsheet but that proved difficult.

 

I've never cruised with NCL so I'm not familiar with how all of their options work (ie beverage packages, pay-to-dine restaurants etc). I'm reading the threads of both of carriers here on Cruise Critic but ultimately what I'd like know is how the two plans (YC versus Haven) compare.

 

Looking for real feedback as opposed to just making a spreadsheet of facts from the websites of the two carriers.

 

Would appreciate any insight you well traveled cruisers may have.

 

Thanks in advance,

Shara

[mom2sons]

Bumping for daytime readers...anyone have any expreinces with both lines?

 

Shara

[time2cruise1]

Can't help you with MSC but here is a list of amenities for the Haven:

 

 

http://www.ncl.com/freestyle-cruise/freestyle-accommodations/haven

[mom2sons]

Thanks, time2cruise1. Much appreciated. It is difficult to decide, lol :D

 

Shara

[WaldosPepper]

For some comparison information that might be useful in your decision, you might want to check out this thread: http://boards.cruisecritic.com/showthread.php?t=1740467&highlight=yacht+club as well as other posts from the OP of that thread. Not an exact match for what you seek, but probably close enough to help you. ;)