Glory vs. Magic

[RMac713]

I was still looking at Glory vs. Celebrity Reflection, but now I add Carnival Magic to the list! It's an eastern itinerary vs. a western. I've never been to any of the eastern ports and Grand Turk, especially, sounds wonderful.

In truth, even the TA I just started talking to is telling me to lean towards Celebrity, but I can't stop thinking about Carnival as an option. So if I do keep them in the mix....any feedback on Glory vs. Magic?

We will both be 53, not taking our adult kids, like to relax, don't gamble at all or drink much (not enough for a package). Would like a balcony room on a higher deck or maybe an ocean suite if it's worth the extra $$; if not a suite would try to get FFTF. Would want to book a pass for the thermal suite.