Which "All-Inclusive" beach escape to pick? - Dominican Republic

[Smooth_J]

So I was looking on the cruise planner, and saw two different beach escapes in the Dominican Republic. One was at Viva Dominicus, and the other was at Catalonia Bayahibe. Has anyone taken either of them as a shore excursion? We have limited time (5 hours), so I want to get my most bang for my buck with the buffet, and other amenities.

[ALTravelGal]

I left a review on the Emotions Resort excursion under the Caribbean/Dominican, Republic Port board, last month. Several YouTube vloggers including ParoDee Jay have videos. If this one is on offer it was worth the money.

Edited June 3 by ALTravelGal