rcl or carnival

[jue]

hi

 

Going to book a cruise having just come of my first one aboard the carnival imagination. loved it. has anyone been on the carnival liberty ship which sails to the baltics or the royal carribean independance of the seas which goes to the canaries and a few other ports aswell.

 

We really do not want to fly next year, we would rather travel down south and get on from there.

 

The baltic tour we were thinking of on 25th august 2009 or the canaries on the 2nd september 2009, will the baltic one be cold at night or day is the ship warm if the weathers cooler outside.. not sure on what to expect on this one but fancy the ports of call.

 

The canaries tour looks good as well i presume this one will be warmer, just dont know what to do, any comments would be great or your experiences

 

many thanks

[going2cruz]

hi

 

Going to book a cruise having just come of my first one aboard the carnival imagination. loved it. has anyone been on the carnival liberty ship which sails to the baltics or the royal carribean independance of the seas which goes to the canaries and a few other ports aswell.

 

We really do not want to fly next year, we would rather travel down south and get on from there.

 

The baltic tour we were thinking of on 25th august 2009 or the canaries on the 2nd september 2009, will the baltic one be cold at night or day is the ship warm if the weathers cooler outside.. not sure on what to expect on this one but fancy the ports of call.

 

The canaries tour looks good as well i presume this one will be warmer, just dont know what to do, any comments would be great or your experiences

 

many thanks

 

Here hope this helps, been on both the scale is from 1-10:

 

CCL

Food -7

Specialty food -11

Ship-6

Activities-8

Shows-6

Staff -7

Ports-9

 

RCCL:

Food -4

Specialty food -5

Ships-11

Activities-4

Shows-4

Staff -10

Ports-4

[Cruising89143]

I would go with itinerary on this one but when it comes to ships, service and crew, RCI is much better than Carnival IMHO.

[going2cruz]

I would go with itinerary on this one but when it comes to ships, service and crew, RCI is much better than Carnival IMHO.

 

 

I agree with his 100% and thats what my scale reflects!

[COCKYMARK]

disagree on activities . rcl much better!! food even.