irvine Posted February 27, 2009 #1 Share Posted February 27, 2009 Hi everyone, I am in a dilemma and hope I can get some opinions. I can't decide between the above 2 ships. I am ok with both itineraries. It just boils down to which ship I want to take. I was on Island Princess (2005) and Westerdam (2006) previously (also to Alaska). I loved the Westerdam, but didn't like the Island Princess much because of the food. The food was poorer quality than what I had in the Westderdam or even Carnvial. But I see in that Sapphire Princess has a higher rating in the reviews than Island Princess. So, I am torn between the 2 now. I prefer more formal cruising with some Asian foods in the menu. I see that HAL has that, not sure if Princess has changed their menu since the last time I was on Island Princess in 2005. I would appreciate anybody with experience with those 2 ships that can offer some advice. I am currently booked on Sapphire for 5/16. Have to decide by 3/2 (final payment date). Zuiderdam would cost me $580 more for my family of 4. Thanks in adance! Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
camrosegirl Posted February 27, 2009 #2 Share Posted February 27, 2009 Hi, Is your Sapphire Princess cruise roundtrip Vancouver? Usually the Sapphire does 1 way Vancouver-Whittier while the Zuiderdam does round trip Vancouver. Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
irvine Posted February 27, 2009 Author #3 Share Posted February 27, 2009 Sapphire is northbound vancouver to whittier. Zuiderdam is roundtrip vancouver. But I am ok either way. My air fare is covered. Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
sammiedawg Posted February 27, 2009 #4 Share Posted February 27, 2009 I've done both ships but neither was in Alaska. IMO Princess dinner food is better than Holland America but HAL has a better buffet. We loved the Sapphire Princess, a very beautiful ship. We enjoyed Zuiderdam the first year or two it sailed, thought it was kind of gaudy. I believe it has been refurbished recently. We like both lines and don't think one line is necessarily superior to the other. Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
hogwildcruzers Posted February 27, 2009 #5 Share Posted February 27, 2009 We have been on both and they are our two favorites....we just sailed on the Sapphire this past Oct......can't say one is better than the other, although the Sapphire is quite larger and we did the dine anytime and enjoyed the several different themed restaurants......I will have to say, that the Sapphire does have real fried eggs on the morning buffet, and they were very good......but HAL does Alaska so well. Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Assateague Island Princes Posted February 28, 2009 #6 Share Posted February 28, 2009 A vote for HAL here - excellent food, free 24-hour room service with large and diverse menu, BEST beds afloat, larger cabins, and THE most wonderful crew around. It would definitely be HAL for us - has the past two times to Alaska and will be again in 2010! In our opinion, they just seem to do it right.:D Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
InTheWASide Posted February 28, 2009 #7 Share Posted February 28, 2009 Hi everyone, I am in a dilemma and hope I can get some opinions. I can't decide between the above 2 ships. I am ok with both itineraries. It just boils down to which ship I want to take. I was on Island Princess (2005) and Westerdam (2006) previously (also to Alaska). I loved the Westerdam, but didn't like the Island Princess much because of the food. The food was poorer quality than what I had in the Westderdam or even Carnvial. But I see in that Sapphire Princess has a higher rating in the reviews than Island Princess. So, I am torn between the 2 now. I prefer more formal cruising with some Asian foods in the menu. I see that HAL has that, not sure if Princess has changed their menu since the last time I was on Island Princess in 2005. I would appreciate anybody with experience with those 2 ships that can offer some advice. I am currently booked on Sapphire for 5/16. Have to decide by 3/2 (final payment date). Zuiderdam would cost me $580 more for my family of 4. Thanks in adance! I'm on the Star Princess May 10 SEA roundtrip with stops in Skagway, Juneau and Ketchikan (and Victoria because of the Jones Act) then on the Zuiderdam on Seoptember 19 with the same stops minus Victoria since its a roundtrip VAN. The Star Princess was a little more last minute. I was going to be doing a coastal 7 day from San Pedro to Vancouver for $850/pp plus tax on an inside... paying for air... etc etc Got wind of a promo that has since expired but was 7 day Alaska out of Seattle with a MINI SUITE for $699/pp plus tax. No air. etc etc How could I refuse? :) If the rates are good enough and you have the time I would say do both, but if you can only do one I would say try the Zuiderdam. You'll be able to see the changes that happened on Westerdam in 2007 AND get a little different ship decor at the same time :) Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Recommended Posts
Archived
This topic is now archived and is closed to further replies.