ATV Jungle vs. Beach? - Carnival

[SJChaput]

I was looking over the shore excursions for Cozumel that are offered by Carnival and was wondering if anyone who has done one or (even better) both can tell me which they liked better or if you have only done one if you can share your experience with me.

 

Also, does anyone have any suggestions for a similar excursion offered by an independent company for cheaper?

 

Thanks.

[kdharris252]

Back in 2006, my husband and I went on the ATV/Beach excursion. The ATV tour was great but the beach they brought us to was eroded from the Hurricane (can't remember which one). It was very rocky - we couldn't even get in the water safely.

 

If I had to do it again (and I will in May) I'll take the ATV Jungle Tour and leave off the beach option.