Labadee Over the Water Cabana at Nellie's or Waterfront at Barefoot?

We currently have an over the water cabana booked at Nellie's Beach in October. However, we have just upgraded to a Grand Suite and it sounds like we might be getting an email from the concierge asking if we want a Barefoot Beach cabana. Which is better Nellie's over the water or Barefoot Waterfront?

No one in our party has children nor mobility issues but we would like to be close to the water but away from the crowds (I know that's probably a lot to ask!)

Barefoot will be less crowded, as it's only for suite guests....anyone can be on Nellies beach, with or without a cabana.

We loved Barefoot Beach. There was also a private buffet for the suite guests. It wasn't crowded, and the beach had fabulous snorkeling as well.