Geoff&Louise

Hope you survived the storm.....:o

Off the Eclipse end of September in CS 1237 (deck 10 hump , port side), was a little vibration first night, and then again one again mid way through cruise, but nothing that kept us awake or spoiled our stateroom comfort.

Deck - 10

Cabin # - 1237

Class – Celebrity Suite

Starboard or Port Side - Port

Bed near?(balcony or bath) – Separate bedroom with separate doors to both lounge and bathroom

Quiet Cabin (With comments on problems. Note if connecting. ) – Yes - very quiet - even with being very close to mid-ship lifts

Balcony View - Give comments on view, noting if location of any obstructions was an issue. – Large balcony on hump with uninterrupted view

Balcony Size? Normal or oversized for class? - Oversize with two chairs, table and cushioned sunbed

Was wind a problem? No

If an aft cabin, was soot a problem? No

Any specific problems with this cabin? None at all great cabin

Any other comments? Good cabin with everything you could want (two TV's, the 55" having a Bose surround system, l-shaped sofa, compact but well appointed bathroom with good quality toiletries) - would definitely choose again

Many thanks for the very informative review and pictures. Certainly looking forward to our cruise with MSC next year.

Arno is right it is Captain Michael no in charge.

 

I had a very interesting chat with John Escobar this afternoon. Now I have ready a some what scathing rebort on these pages last weeks suggesting that he was a less than perfect MCC but as chemmo also said at the time I have do differ with that poster. John has been - So far - an excelent host. I will elaborate further as our cruises unfolds.

 

One little gem He did pass pass while chatting this afternoon was that in the forth coming refuurb (revolution) there will be additional suites added to the s class ships possibly around the sky lounge.

Dear groryjm, I am glad than you are getting a good service from Mr J A Escobar, as did chemmo, but as the poster mentioned in your above thread, for myself and my wife, the actions of the MCC completely spoilt our X suite experience, and we never received an apology from him. Sorry to post again, but this has just stirred up a bad memory.

What this means. ? If I have a classic beverage package I cannot order a Martin at Martini bar even if I'm willing to pay the up charge ?

I did not know that the classic package have restrictions

 

 

 

Sent from my iPad using Forums

Hi Sea Dogy, we are just back from Eclipse. You can buy a Martini on the Classic package and pay the $3 up charge (we did it a few times 😀). Most Martini's were $14 compared to the $11 max on the Classic package

Sorry to hear about your experience in Michael’s Club. As a general rule the MCC has been top notch on our previous Celebrity cruises.

We are sailing on Eclipse in December. Do you, by any chance remember the MCC’s name?

 

Randy

 

 

Sent from my iPhone using Forums

Hi Randy,

His name is John Escobar. You will see from other reviews that previous guests have reported a good service from this MCC. Perhaps we were just unlucky. For us, him running away from the issue and not dealing with problem to hand after several chasers was just rude an unacceptable. As you can see this was a small blip in the overall very good Celebrity experience.

Geoff

Don’t know when or where you booked your cruise but lately the suites get all 4 perks. I know many think that it is standard but it is a promo that they now have. The promo doesn’t always apply to some special discount pricing.

 

Capt Leo does have many “girlfriends”. The ladies sure do love him. One of the many social captains on X.

 

Thanks for taking the time to post. We have our first suite booked on the Eclipse and your comments about Luminae help to confirm spending the extra over Aqua.

 

Other than avoiding the host how were the drinks and drink service in Michaels Club?

 

Happy cruising 🌊🚢🇺🇸🌞

Unfortunately being from the UK has its disadvantages, and the US offers seem far better and we do not benefit from the "bigger / best" promotions and up to 4 perks for Suites. In the UK, I suspect we get slightly cheaper cruise pricing but usually only one perk of a "free classic drinks package". I am sure overall we all pay roughly the same but their offers just reflect the different way Celebrity market their products in different markets. That said, in the UK they are currently offering 50% off for the second guest. Concierge aside, we did enjoy our time in Michael's Club, it was never crowded and the bar staff were all very friendly and efficient. They were happy to make up cocktails for us, and even go to the coffee shop for us to get a speciality coffee if they weren't too busy. Also the afternoon tea on sea days was very good and served by the Butlers. It is certainly a good perk for suite guests when you want somewhere to relax peacefully in very comfortable surroundings.

Cruised on the Eclipse 4 times so far including Norway this May. Off again this 8th Oct to Canaries and have always had classic drinks package. Also always end up in Martini bar in the evenings but have never had to pay additional $3.00 for a drink. Did you order drinks that were in the premium package without realising it? Only other drinks in there are the Martinis which cost a kings ransom. Not for me.

We bought Martinis that were $14 each, and knew that they were over the $11 limit under the Classic Package, and just charged the extra $3 per drink. It was worth the $3 to try the various flavours they did. Also fun to watch them make them throwing bottles around.

Celebrity EclipseReview – Portugal & the Azores – 11 nights from 17 September 2017

This was our first Celebrity Cruise, and we treatedourselves to a Celebrity Suite (Stateroom 1237).

Overall we had a very good experience with one exceptionthat unfortunately took the shine off our overall holiday.

Ship overall:

Definitely 5 star, with everything very clean and in goodworking order, and despite being full, never seemed over crowded, with plentyof seats available in all lounges and sundeck.

Crew:

With one exception, all excellent and very hard working.Upon boarding the ship, my first experience with a crew member was a maletoilet attendant (I wish I had taken his name) as when I went to the toilet hewelcomed me with a big smile saying "welcome to my office", and uponleaving, said "thank you for visiting and come again soon". Hisfriendliness brought a big smile to my face, and in general, this was my experiencewith virtually all of crew members.

The Senior staff were very visible throughout the cruise,especially Captain Leo, who was at the bottom of the gangway at every port ofcall wishing all guests a good day, and as you have may read in other reviewswas known as the "voice from above" in his light-hearted andinformative daily information updates. I also think the ladies enjoyed havingtheir photographs taken with him!

Restaurants:

We were lucky enough to have access to the Luminaerestaurant as a suite guest. I cannot praise the quality of the food and allstaff high enough. This was without question the highlight of our cruise andeven when not really hungry enough for a full lunch on sea days, we still wentjust for one small course for the welcoming experience. As mentioned all staffwere excellent, but special thanks for to the Maître D' Nedad, as well asRoxana, Victor, David, Uilana and the sommelier, Enesto. Every meal was a greatexperience and they could not do enough for you and from the first nightremembered you food and drink preferences. If you are lucky enough to be ableto treat yourselves to a suite - I fully recommend this just for access toLuminae.

Prior to our cruise, we also pre-booked for Tuscan Grill andMurano. Firstly, Murano that was booked for my birthday. This is a high qualityrestaurant and a great experience, especially the show cooking at your table. Icertainly recommend the Lobster Tail and Crepe. Is it worth $50 extra perperson, probably for the experience, but Luminae is a very hard act to follow.

Whilst several other reviews also praise Tuscan Grill, unfortunatelywe had a bad experience at Tuscan Grill (where we paid an extra $45 perperson). Prior to the cruise I had advised of my wife's cheese allergy(something Luminae were aware of in advance), and I even went to Tuscan Grillearlier in the day of our booked visit to mention her allergy again. When thewaiter came round with the bread options, two were cheese related and the thirdoption was touching the other cheese related bread so cross contaminationissues. My wife had to therefore decline, but was not offered other bread fromthe kitchen that had not been contaminated. Also, as Tuscan Grill is next totwo other speciality restaurants, different bread could have easily beensourced. Starters were ok. When going to the restroom my napkin was taken butnever replaced so I had to ask for another. Then for main course I ordered thefilet mignon, asking for "medium rare". When this arrived it was"medium / to well done". Normally I may have accepted this, but asour experience hadn't been great so far with the bread and napkin issue (andbearing in mind I have paid an extra $45 for this meal) I rejected the steak(which wasn't taken well by the waiter). Some ten minutes later when a newfilet was delivered (by which time my wife had finished hers main course) itwas still not medium rare, more well done! (It should be noted that I had filetmignon on our first night in Luminae, ordered medium rare, and was cookedperfectly). I could not be bothered to return it again as I had lost myappetite by then so ate some of it - and it should also be noted that my sideorders were not replaced either so these were luke warm at best when thereplacement steak arrived. Finally I ordered Cheesecake for dessert, which wasfairly dry and I could not finish. At the end of the meal I expressed mydisappointment to the Maître D', who whilst was very apologetic and offered forus to return to Tuscan another day at no "extra cost", I politely advisedthat as Luminae was so good I did not really want to return and felt that I hadwasted $90. He said he would see what he could do and left if there (seecomments below re Michael’s Club Concierge).

We did not try Qusine but heard good reviews.

We had a wander around the Ocaenview Café a couple of timesand the buffet seemed very varied and of high quality. On a couple of the seaday afternoons we did go up there for an ice-cream (and was very good, andreally no point paying the extra for gelato in Café Al Bacio). On sea days thelunch times did seem fairly busy, and available seats had to be searched for.

Stateroom:

We had a Celebrity Suite Cabin no 1237. This was veryspacious and clean (showing some signs of tiredness to a couple of the units,especially the dressing table), and we enjoyed having a separate bedroom andtwo TV's, so that if one of us wanted a rest, the other could watch TV withoutdisturbing the other. The balcony was spacious and had a comfortable sunlounger. We ordered breakfast in our stateroom twice, very good, and also lunchto watch the sail into Lisbon, again very good. Whilst we did not use theservices of our Butler much (Peter) was he always there and polite. The stewardMaynard was also very good and kept the room very clean and re-stocked thefridge and toiletries.

Michael’s ClubConcierge:

Unfortunately, this is where our cruise was spoilt. TheConcierge is meant to be there to resolve any issues we have. Early in the cruise I had mentioned to himthat there did not seem to be cabin breakfast menu cards in our room (as youorder the night before and leave them hanging outside on your cabin door when yougo to bed). He said he would sort this, but I had to chase again the followingday. An early sign that he did not do his duty and follow up on requests toensure they had been actioned. But our main issue was how he handled our poor TuscanGrill experience. On the morning after our meal in the Tuscan Grill (asmentioned above), I advised the Concierge that I was unhappy about theexperience and he confirmed that he would resolve the matter (after all,that is a key part of his job description). This was on the Thursday morning.As we had not heard anything from him or anyone else for that matter some fourdays later, early on the Monday morning I specifically went to him to find outwhat was happening about our complaint. His response was, "Oh haven't theycontacted you?". I'm sorry, but someone in his senior position should havefollowed up on the matter to ensure that it had been resolved, and as we hadseen him at least twice every day for the past 4 days he could have asked ifeverything was ok, I again expressed my huge disappointment that we had notheard anything. Again he promised that he would sort the issue immediately.Later that night (some 11 hours later) when going into Michael's Lounge for anight cap, the Concierge was in there, but rather than engaging with us toupdate us on what he had been doing to resolve our complaint, he saw us, lookstartled, and make a very quick exit and never returned. I found this to beextremely rude and very unprofessional. By this point I was very annoyed as Ihad given him several opportunities to resolve our issue and therefore had nooption than to take matters further and went down to guest relations tobitterly complain about his actions. The following morning I had a call fromEunice, the Guest Relations Manager, and after explaining the events that hasoccurred over the preceding days, she was very apologetic, fully acknowledgedthat the Concierge had acted inappropriately and not carried out his dutiesproperly, and offered to resolve the matter by refunding our Tuscan Grillcharge, offered free internet for the last two days sea days of our cruise anda token towards the cost of another Celebrity Cruise to try and keep ourloyalty. I accepted this in good grace (albeit I have still yet to receive the$90 refund as this was not taken off our on-board bill), and later that day didget a call from the Tuscan Grill Maître D' to again apologise and trying totempt us back to Tuscan so that he could show that our bad experience was a oneoff. However, at no point did we ever get a word of apology from the Concierge.I obviously felt uncomfortable that I had to complain about him and takematters to a higher level to resolve the issue, and as he made no attempt toget in contact in any way, felt very uneasy about returning to Michael’s Club(as I did not was to cause an issue / embarrassment in front of other guests)or participate in any of the activities that we had been invited to where theConcierge could be present. Therefore due to his actions, we missed out onfurther visits to Michael’s Club for 3 days, a helipad port sail in, a bridgetour, and the more relaxed disembarkation offered to suite guests whenreturning to Southampton.

In fairness, I know other guests have been complimentaryabout the Concierge, perhaps we were just unlucky and caught him on a bad fewdays. Still, I understand that the will be a new appointment of a Suite Managersoon on the Eclipse and the Concierge and Butlers will report to this newposition so hopefully that will ensure that a similar problem does not happento another guest in the future.

Bars:

We had the "Classic Drinks Package" as part of ouroriginal booking offer, and found this to be more than adequate to meet ouralcoholic drink tastes (i.e. any drink up to $11), and the package includedgood quality wines at dinner. We did go to the Martini Bar a couple of times(good experience) and paid an extra $3 for each drink.

All bar staff are extremely quick an efficient and veryfriendly. Our favourite was Nevad, the Senior Bar Manager in the Sky Lounge,who remembered what we drank every time we went there (very impressive whenthere are over 2,800 guests that can use the bar).

We often grabbed a coffee to go at Café Al Bacio and neversaw large queues, maybe three of four people in front of us, but were servedvery quickly.

Art Auctions:

We have never really taken an active interest in Art, and inaddition to Luminae, our cruise was enhanced by the Park West team who made usnovices feel very welcome, were never pushy, and spent a lot of time with usexplaining the artists and their works, and enabling us to gain anunderstanding and appreciation. So much so, that we bought two small picturesto start our collection!

Entertainment:

We went to several shows. Not all to our own personal taste,but were all very professional and of high visual quality. The singers anddancers were all above average. The comedian was good. We also enjoyed thevarious live acts on various locations throughout the ship every day. TheEntertainments Director, Eddy, was very good, and his daily shows on the CruiseTV channel with Giuseppe updating you on the day's activities were not to bemissed - a great double act and very funny.

Also the Celebrity Life programme of on-board entertainmentwas very good and varied, from quizzes in the Sky Lounge, dance classes, to apaper plane making and throwing competition. You could just choose what tookyour fancy on the day. The Hot Glass show is also very worth watching.

Ports of call:

La Coruna

Nice town with plenty to do for the day with ship dockednear town centre. We pre-booked a coach tour with Tour4Cruises that cost €15for a two and a half tour in a clean and air conditioned coach that did 4 stopsin and around the area at the key tourist spots. Great guide who was veryfriendly and informative. Well worth the money.

Funchal (Madeira)

Our first time in Madeira and we loved it and want to goback for a few days at some point in the future. Funchal is a lovely city thatreminded us of the French Riviera with a good seafront and places to see andvisit. We did the local Red Bus Hop-On / Hop – Off to get a feel for the areaand the round trip lasted about 90 minutes and was very picturesque. Cost was€17. Audio commentary was hard to hear on the bus due to a faulty system. Itwas about a 15 minute brisk walk from the port to the town centre.

Ponta Delgada(Azores)

Another lovely place to visit for the day, although not thatmuch to do in the town centre itself, albeit the ship docks right in the centreof town. We pre-booked a Celebrity trip to the very scenic crater lakes andhave come back with some great photos. The tour guide was very good and overallgood value for money at £33 each.

Lisbon

We have been to Lisbon before and it is one of our favouriteEuropean cities with so much to see and do within a relatively small area. Alsowe were lucky to have a port side cabin for a beautiful sail into Lisbon ataround 1 o’clock. As we knew the town well, we decided to pre-book a Celebritytrip to Sintra and Cascais. Both a very different and beautiful. Cascais in avery pretty fishing town close to upmarket Estoril, and Sintra is a wonderfulworld heritage site. The trip only gave us an hour in each town, but that wasenough to give a feel for the area and a very strong desire to go back to spenda couple of days in each. You can easily get to both by train from the centreof Lisbon. The 4 hour trip cost £31, and was good value with a very good andefficient guide.

Summary:

All in all a very good overall experience, which for us, wasunfortunately spoiled by the actions of one particular individual that we havedirectly followed-up with Celebrity is to ensure that it doesn't happen to a anotherguest in the future.

Would we sail with Celebrity again - yes, certainly the bestship we have sailed on to date.

I am slightly concerned to hear this as I had heard on other threads (and elsewhere that Mr Escobar was good). What were your concerns? Have raised this elsewhere on CC?

Hi groryjm, I am sure other guests like Chemmo had a good experience, regretably we did not. I do not think it is appropriate to expand on the issue we had, that could have been easily resolved. However, in summary, due to inaction of the Concierge after three polite chasers, including him walking out of Michael's Club to avoid me as he had not carried out his duties, I had no option to complain at a higher level. To a greater extent this issue was resolved by a senior member of the Eclipse team, who fully acknowledged the significant short comings of the Concierge and offered appropriate compensation. However, due to the high level of ill feelings towards the Concierge we did not want our holiday to be spoiled further and therefore avoided all further contact with him, which therefore excluded us from using Michael's Club and participating in a helipad sail away, a bridge tour, and the benefits of a relaxed disembarkation when arriving back into Southampton. It was a pity that one crew member spoiled our overall experience as all other members were excellent, especially everyone in Luminae. I will be taking this further with Celebrity to ensure that the Concierge concerned carries out his duties in a more appropriate matter in the future. Perhaps the Eclipse is in need of a Suite Manager to ensure this.

Just off Eclipse, no suite manager but John worked hard enough for two people.....

 

You are in for a treat with John looking after you!

Chemmo, I was on the same cruise as you, but regrettably I cannot say the same about the Michael's Club Concierge who did not follow-up on a complaint we made to him and had to escalate the matter. I am now following up with a significant complaint letter as he actions really spoiled our Celebrity Cruise overall experience. IMHO he is not up to the job of looking after suite guests.

We are on the Seaside next May, and will happily support rebuilding the local economy of the ports visited. I can't begin to understand how some families effected by Irma must be feeling right now.

Day 7 - Tallin, Estonia Final

 

We headed back to the meeting point to catch the transfer. The Celebrity Daily indicated we needed our passports, but no one ever asked for pier side.

 

 

We had dinner in Luminae while the ship departed port. By the end of the dinner, a boat was nearing our window to pick up the pilot who navigated us out of Tallinn.

 

 

The next day is St.Petersburg, with an early start and a hellish passport control. We hung out on the balcony.

 

OH filled out the room service menu for delivery at 6AM and called it a night.

 

I'm a day behind now on my reporting. Four consecutive port days it's a little hard to keep up.

 

This was the sunset leaving Tallinn.

 

Stunning sunset photo! Please keep them coming.

Many thanks for the great and very informative review. Certainly makes me more excited about our cruise next year on the Seaside in May.

We are on the Eclipse in just over 5 weeks for the first time, so any tips during your cruise would be very helpful. Have a great trip.

Not sure if you have seen the above MSC clip of the Yacht Club sun deck? May answer some questions. Was released a couple of months ago. Looks great and am also getting excited.

Bea ... I was referring to the three changes made to the Seaside in December and the one they changed after final payment on the first Divina TA.

Hi Sidari,

Am curious as to what the changes to the Seaside in December were (apart from their new Island) as we have booked the Seaside for 19 May 18.

Many thanks

Geoff

Hi Geoff and Louise,

 

We are regular suite guests on Celebrity. We find Michael's Club a great venue to meet others for pre and post dinner drinks. They also provide a great afternoon tea although we still prefer the butler to serve ours in suite. Just ask if this is your preference.

 

Michael's also offer some musical events which we really enjoy. The concierge will give you details of these. There is usually also a helipad 'sail away' from at least one port. If you let the concierge know of any particular areas of interest you have on the ship (bridge tour, galley tour, theatre back stage tour...) she will sort them out for you.

 

I do recommend you try at least one or two speciality restaurants. Tuscan Grill is our favourite if we are leaving a port just as it is going dark...You can enjoy those fabulous wake views and the port slowly disappear as you leisurely dine...Murano's is our favourite dining venue, make sure one of you orders something prepared tableside....

 

Sincere best wishes for a great cruise!

Great advice, thank you

We were on the Eclipse for 14 days a few months ago and never had to wait for a table and it was always quite busy when we went for lunch or dinner.

 

We did have a special anniversary dinner for which my husband had requested a quiet window table. Since there could be a wait for a particular table, they suggested we wait in Michael's Club and called the MC concierge when the table was ready. We were pampered in Michael's while we waited and then pampered in Luminae - a special night!

Many thanks

We have only had Luminae on two cruises, but no waits other than if we arrive just after someone else, we wait while they are escorted to their table and then we are escorted to ours. So maybe 90 seconds? Two minutes?

 

On one breakfast we got there to find it almost completely filled, and the maitre d' apologized that "our" table wasn't available. It was absolutely no problem but she thought we'd be upset or something.

Many thanks

We will look out for you in Michael's!

 

Is it your first Celebrity cruise? Any more questions re Eclipse generally or the suite experience, feel free to ask!

Hi chemmo, we are booked in a Celbrity Suite, so any tips to help us make the most of our first Celrity cruise would be greatly appreciated. And hope to say hi in Michael's.

Remember lunch is only served on sea days. We tend to find the lunch menu a bit heavy. We will often just ask for a soup and salad. Three Luminae meals a day is simply overload! If we are going to lunch in Luminae we will just have coffee and croissants in the suite for breakfast....

 

We were on Eclipse in May. We had no issues at all when we dined in Luminae but we usually dine quite early....in our experience over several cruises there can be a bit of a queue 7.30 ish but only a few minutes.

 

Hope you have a great cruise! We are back on board in September and so looking forward to it!

Many thanks for the info - we are sailing on the 17th September, so if same cruise - see you on it

We are due to sail on the Eclipse in a few weeks. With respect to the Luminae restaurant, has anyone experienced a problem having to wait for a table for either lunch or dinner? Many thanks.

Celebrity now allows passengers to pay the difference for drinks between the cost and the Classic allowance. Example, Classic allows up to $9. Drink is $12, you would pay $2 plus the gratuity on the difference. If you are not drinkers, it probably wouldn't pay to upgrade. Specialty coffees, teas, juices, bottled water are all included in the classic package. Incidentally, the desserts and pastries at Café al Bacio are free even without any beverage packages. I don't drink the smoothies, so I can't speak to that.

 

The unlimited internet package only allows one device at a time to be logged in. Discounted packages are often available in sales before your cruise, so keep a lookout for them. Be aware that once on board there are other internet packages available that are not unlimited. Depending on how much you plan to use it onboard you may want to visit the internet café and see what other plans fit your needs. Also, most times, midway through the cruise there are pro-rated internet packages available for lower cost.

Many thanks for the useful tips