My wife and I brought a bottle of wine each, for consumption in our stateroom, on each of our eleven HAL cruises over the years. Post covid we have been on four cruises (after corkage fee's for this wine was instituted) and never charged corkage until our most recent departure (January) out of FLL. The stupid thing is we had the Have It All package. Fifteen glasses of wine per day each, already paid for, if we wanted.
To have a bottle or two for the cabin is just a convenience to enjoy a glass from time to time without having to going out to a bar to get wine. From now on we will forget the expense of bringing on our own wine and drink HAL's when we have the "Have It All".
G