Cruised on the Encore with wife and 2 daughters (11 and 14) got a Balcony Room on 14 for the wife and I and an Inside Room for the Girls right across the hall
Initial fare around $3k for the balcony room and $2K for the inside room
Prior Cruises 2 Disney 2014, 2015 followed by 1 NCL (Escape) 2016
Boat was very nice, incredible finishes everywhere and looked brand new.
Incredibly crowded almost everywhere, bumping into people at the breakfast buffet, nearly impossible to fine a chair on the pool deck long time to get a drink at the pool bars etc. Dining reservations were hit and miss
Coffee was average to below average quality and why dont they put some coffee out at each floor by the elevators?
Food quality was good to great - buffet and free dining options were adequate- Cagney's, Ocean Blue, Los Lobos and Food Republic were all tried by at least a pair of us and were excellent.
Ports
were were rerouted from GSC to Nassau either due to "Tinder Maint." or high winds depending on who you asked. Little Disappointing but we had a good beach day at Blue Lagoon, requires a 30 min boat ride and some cost but not a big deal
St Thomas- Private taxi to Magens Bay, very nice beach but again very crowded
Tortola - only walked around the shops, not much there less than an hour off the boat mostly used as a sea day
Puerto Plata (Taino Bay) - Incredible Nice Cruise Port, by far the best I have seen as far as the immediate "Port area" is concerned. Very nice large resort style pool with multiple bars and shops all brand new. Anyone looking for an easy port day plan it here (unless you want to Zip Line) you can walk to the pool / resort area and its all free including pool cabanas (except drinks) 14 year old and I did the "Zip and Dip" Tour and it was very nice
Sea Days we mostly hung out on the pool deck if we could find a spot , or rested in the room. , girls and I did the slides. wife used the spa quite a bit -for Lunch generally just a snack at the buffet and only went below deck 14 for dinner
Overall Pros
Quality and design of the Boat
Food Quality
Ports
Love using the Balcony
Cons
Crowded Pool Deck
Nickle and Dime aspect for some items
Crowded Bars / wait for drink
Long line to get off at ports
Crowded breakfast buffet
Not sure if this is right place to ask this, but based on my views above would anyone recommend another line such as MSC or Celebrity next time? I would not mind paying a little more( but not Haven Prices). I'm also not crazy about being locked into a 6:30 or 8:00 diner time all week, Id rather take my chances with a reservation each day I choose based on that days schedule
Thanks and Im happy to answer any questions or expand more