I have a feeling that I might have been on the same cruise you have just written about.
Vista Western Caribbean. March 9 to March 16.
I second everything you have said in your post. We had the same experiences as you had
This is not the standards that we have been used to on previous Oceania cruises. Our dinner in the Polo was great Tom a Hawk veal chop and the sides were inedible. The mushrooms were over cooked, the baked potato was Luke warm. We ate in the buffet more on this trip then ever before. The Wave had the best food. Food isn’t the reason why we cruise, but on a high end cruise and for the money we paid it should have been better.
I too, am looking for another luxury cruise line to take next. I don’t know if going back to the Riveria or the Marina would be good or has the quality of food also not living up to their standards.