I will not even try to counter all of the misinformation contained here. I have been presenting my personal experiences and what I have been told by the people involved. This has occurred over my past 10-15 cruises that I am basing my post on. Now, there a number of "know it alls" that believe they know the only truth that exists. So be it, I will continue to enjoy the "concierge" perk as it has been presented to me. The rest of you can follow which ever path you believe works for you. I am done here.