Which cruise

[cruising to paradise]

Which cruise would you choose ? The southern on Summit to the islands that include St Thomas, St. Lucia, etc or the southern that includes St Marteen, Barbados,etc.

[chief joe]

Thats a hard one all four are great stops. If you have never been to any of them flip a coin.

[CaribbeanBound]

Lay out all of the ports.

[cruising to paradise]

San Juan,St Marteen,Dominica,Grenada,Tobago,Barbados or

San Juan,St Thomas,St. Croix,St. John,St. Kitts, St Lucia the only ones we have been to are St. Marteen and St. Thomas and San Juan. Really like St. Marteen

[CaribbeanBound]

Both look good. I'd take the San Juan, St Thomas, St. Croix, St. John, St. Kitts, St Lucia as we are REALLY fond of the Virgin Islands and surrounding area.

[JRarey]

Which ship and line is doing St. John. Is it St. John the Island or is it St. John, Antiqua?

 

I must of missed that sailing when I was looking to book my cruise, which I just did yesterday!

[warmwinds]

We've been on both of these cruises and really liked them both. The one with Tobago (out of San Juan) I think had NOT enough sea days - we felt like we were running every minute. So I'd do the St. Lucia one again, it was a little longer I believe (is it still 10 days?), great ports and enough sea days.

[CaribbeanBound]

Actually, there is no St. John, Antiqua.

It's St. Johns, Antiqua.

 

I did assume (maybe incorrectly) that it is St. John USVI

 

We were not really fond of St. Johns.

[tcocktail]

Both trip are terrific , I would go on the one furthest away. We just never know what is going to happen and the Virgin Islands are a lot easier to get to.

[Aggie]

Can't go wrong with either one, but I really like Barbados (for the somewhat British feel and the friendly people) and Dominica (for the snorkeling and scuba in the champagne bubbles) over St. Croix. If the sailing dates both work, I would go with choice one.