Snorkeling in Freeport

[TonyCruise]

Cruising to the Bahamas this April and would like to plan a snorkel excursion for my family during a stop in Freeport. I have found 3 options and would love some opinions:

 

1) Carnival has the following excursion: "Spend a day in the sun over one of the many pristine reefs snorkeling off Lucaya Beach. Sail to the reef on a beautiful 72-ft catamaran, Snorkel among the abundance of marine life and coral formations in this area".

 

2) Paradise Cove Beach Resort which is supposed to have good snorkeling and a beach - it is near Deadman's Reef. You snorkel from the shore.

 

3) Pat & Diane's snorkel tour - private snorkel excursion on their boat, the Fantasia. "Cruise along the shore line and Lucayan Canal".

 

Any help that you can provide would be most appreciated! :)

 

Thanks,

Tony