Back to Back Dawn or Freedom for 25th Anniversary??

[doitallWMB]

OK. We are down to 4 trips this October and November this year. We will either book the Carnival Dream for a back to back out of Canaveral, The Carnival Freedom back to back out of Fort Lauderdale, The NCL Dawn for 11 days from Miami or the NCL Sun just refurbed out of Canaveral for a back to back. As usual, Carnival is a little less expensive, but very little. We had asked several questions about the Freedom in another post and it is the front runner now. My TA thinks to reserve the current pricing and to make sure we are in the same cabin we should book soon. Help please. What are your opinions? Please no flaming of one line or the other. We did like freestyle on the NCL Jewel a couple years ago, but the Carnival Glory was the most fun...