Which Carnival Snorkeling Excursion in Belize?

[brilliantseas]

For those of you who have done a snorkeling excursion through Carnival in Belize, which one do you prefer? They all seem so similar in the descriptions, I can't decide which one would be best.

 

For those of you who would suggest that Carnival's excursions are more expensive, I am well aware of that, and normally I'd plan with an independent provider recommended here on CruiseCritic, but I think in Belize, I'm willing to pay the premium to have the snorkeling boat pick us up right from the ship rather than dealing with the tender process to and from Belize City.

 

Here are the options:

 

Barrier Reef Snorkel with Beach Break - $69.95

Goff's Caye Snorkeling - $59.99

Sergeant's Cay Snorkel Adventure - $62.95

 

We've also given a little thought to the Discover Scuba excursion for $119.95.

 

Any recommendations?