2 IS vs. 1 OV ~ WHAT WOULD YOU DO?

[QTPieRye]

I have 2 possible solutions for adding a 4th passenger to my current reservation which is a cabin for 3 on the Upper Deck (4D - 6446):

 

Option 1: Add son as 4th passenger and upgrade from 4B to OV (Cabin 2430) directly down aft elevator from us for $701.00;

 

OR

 

Option 2: Add a 3rd cabin 4D on the upper deck aft close to our other cabins for son and move daughter from 3rd passenger from existing 4D cabin to new cabin for $994.00.

 

The difference is $293.00. DH and I simply cannot decided which is the best option!!!!! What are your thoughts? Is it worth the extra $293.00 to have the extra room, extra bathroom and cabins close together? Given the little amount of time we are in the cabins, not sure if I can justify the extra cost, but at the same time not sure we want our family split!

 

WHAT WOULD YOU DO?

[ATL2LAS]

2 bathrooms will always trump 1:D

[thomarvin]

I would definately go for the 2 cabins. 4 in any cabin is tight. Do able. but tight. If the $300 is manageable for you, do it. no question!!

[thomarvin]

Another plus is every one gets a "real bed" rather than a sleep sofa and/or a pull down.

[QTPieRye]

I've gone ahead and booked the 3rd cabin. Since my kids are all 16+, it just didn't make sense to cram them into 1 cabin and have them on a different floor :) This will ultimately work out well for everyone and I will cruise with the peace of mind of knowing that my kids are right across the hall!