Deciding between RCCL Navigator and Carnival Magic

[MeilzB]

Hi, we're deciding between the Navigator of the Seas and the Magic for an upcoming anniversary cruise. I have cruised a ton, but only on Carnival 1x or 2x and it's been about 10 years since our last cruise. We aren't picky, but do enjoy good food and having fun. Looking forward most to getting away without our kiddos and just relaxing. I'd be curious to hear your pros and cons on the Navigator vs the Magic. Thanks in advance!

[Sam.Seattle]

We prefer RCL hands down....

 

You might get more replies on the main boards vs. the Gulf departures.

[MeilzB]

Oops! I'll repost in the proper spot - thanks for the head's up!

[houstoncruisers2001]

We prefer RCL hands dow.

Amen to that. Been on both the Navigator and Magic and for what we prefer there's no comparison.