Magic or Sunshine

[tmg698]

For those who have been on both if you just base your decision on the ship which would you choose.:confused:

[2docsgirl]

can't wait to go on the Magic next May

Edited October 15, 2015 by 2docsgirl

[rolloman]

I do not think it is a hard decision...Magic hands down. Sunshine is the old Destiny. Nothing more than an old ship they changed the name of an then added a ton of extra passengers.

[MrzDeeDee]

Im trying to decide between Magic and Splendor...

[Crusin Hogs]

Magic ! I would not sail on Sunshine if I was given a free cruise on it

[StaceySteveDMB]

I don't sail on the Magic until April but have sailed on the Sunshine twice and sailing again in a month. The Sunshine is a great ship with a ton of extras that we absolutely love! We have not experienced any of the issues that people have mentioned (I wonder if those people have even been on the ship) other than a crowded lido deck pool, but what ship in the fleet doesn't have a crowded lido deck pool?

[tiggerman101]

I certainly don't want to come off as a troll, but I am pretty vocal about my dislike for the Sunshine. It really is my least favorite ship that I have ever been on. It is very congested and crowded at times and the layout is terrible.

 

I enjoyed the Magic quite a bit however.