Nevis Sail Away or Grand Tour of St. Kitts?

[OBX Cruisers]

Our first visit to St.Kitts. Trying to decide between catamaran sail to Nevis with beach time at Pinney's Beach (ship's tour) and tour of St. Kitts with Thenford Grey that includes island tour and beach time at Cockleshell or South Friar's. Will have all day cat sail with Aristocat in Tortola. Concerned that the sail to Nevis will be on a crowded cat. Is it a good experience? Have heard really good things about Thenford Grey's tour and since it's our first time on St. Kitts have probably talked ourselves into this option. Both will be all day but Thenford Grey's tour is also less expensive. Am I missing anything here in our decision?

[paul58]

Skip the sail and go with Thenford's Grand Tour. Save your trip to Nevis when you come and stay in St Kitts on a vacation.