Going crazy trying to decide Carnival Victory or Star Princess

[dbarry]

I am trying to plan my next cruise (October 2005). I love the western caribbean and have sailed there three times, once on Princess and two times with RCCL. I would really like to cruise with Carnival again (only other cruise with Carnival was on the Fantasy). The Victory and the Star Princess have just about the same itinery, the only difference is that Princess stops at their island. My sweet husband has made it even more difficult by suggesting the eastern caribbean route on either the Victory or the Caribbean Princess. Someone please! Help! Any advice, opinions or suggestions on how to choose? Has anyone sailed on these ships, and has an opinion on which gave them the better cruise experience?

 

Thank you all in advance!

Darlene

[halos]

I'm sorry I can't help you because I haven't sailed either ship, I just wanted to tell you how I wish I had your dilema!!!!

Whatever ship you chose, it will be the right choice! Just relax and pick one and have a great time!!!

[marco]

If the itinerary is slightly different, if there is a port or two that are critical that you go to, choose that one. If not, which ever one you can get the best deal for the accomodations you want would be my choice.