I was on the Oasis from 10/22 to 10/29. D+ with 28 cruises behind us. Even my DH and I don't like the same shows on most ships. On this sailing:
* We sat through about 25 minutes of Cats but that was all we could endure. Both agreed.
* Ice Show - Frozen in Time - started a little slow but picked up quickly and was enjoyed by both of us.
*Aqua80 (water show) - amazing! Colorful, athletic (to say the least) fast paced, clever, etc. etc. Both agreed>
*Comedians were loud, rude and crude. Not a huge fan of filthy language. (I've heard it, not a prude, just don't want to sit and listen to it on vacation).
*everything else was excellent on the cruise...food, service, weather except tha twe were unable to stop at CoCo Cay because of the terrible wind there (as told to us by the Captain).
We loved Grease, he loved Momma MIa, I despised it and anything to do with ABBA.. Chicago was so-so and We Will Rock You was fantastic. To each, his own! Just have fun!