Jump to content

docmark

Members
  • Posts

    809
  • Joined

Posts posted by docmark

  1. 1 hour ago, cruiseluv said:

    Difficult to believe it would make sense for them to sail with those low numbers

    We plan to go on October 12 cruise, IF in next 6-8 weeks it appears that Cruise will not be cancelled. We have not yet deposited or reserved, and I tend to believe there are others like us, so they may get to 50% (or close to it) capacity.

  2. I wonder if any "regular" Regent cruisers have copy of "premium red wine " menu, those that  are NOT covered (free), and requires extra payment.

     

    Thanks in advance. (please don't respond by telling me to call Regent! )

  3. 16 minutes ago, Paulchili said:

    I did it today - one award and one paid ticket cancelled - easy-peasy, no fees.

    Kudos to United.

    Paul, can I ask if your cancelled UA flight was related to a cancelled Cruise ,or you haven't cancelled cruise yet? I have a cruise in mid-august, and (Miles) flight with UA , neither cancelled yet

  4. "if you don't mind my asking: Other than the possibility of plenty of disposable income, what makes the large cabin, butler, etc. attractive enough to warrant a cabin cost difference  equal to an entire second cruise?"

     

    First of all  I don't consider myself being in the category of "plenty of disposable income" !!

    From start of cruising many years ago, I did not feel comfortable in "small" cabins, and as we started cruising more, I tried to secure bigger cabins ,500-1000+ sq. . However, in past 2 years, we have been cruising much  more frequently and planning to continue that way, so last trip on Marina, which was planned a year before, was the last "big cabin" I plan to take (my wife leaves all the travelling arrangement to me !!),  in order to afford more cruises.

    Very likely almost all our future cruises will be on cabins of PH size .I still will be inclined not to go any smaller, for example, I have looked at veranda cabins (Oceania) and  the bathrooms were absolutely too tight for me !!.  

  5. Of course the comparison is between 2 cabins of completely different size, OC >2.5 times bigger than PH 

     

    Paul, as you noted, itinerary definitely affects the cost,  our cruise had only one sea day, but I believe since it was "off season" for a west coast cruise, price was more attractive 

  6. 13 hours ago, Paulchili said:

    It’s very easy math - you know how much you paid/pp for Marina  and for the Crystal.

    Divide each by the number of days of the cruise and you’ve got the pre diem/pp 😊

    Hi Paul

     

    Here is the comparison: Oceania per diem came out to $1312 per diem for 2 of us, and Crystal per diem was $1045  per diem for 2

    • Like 2
  7. 2 minutes ago, Paulchili said:

    Thank you.

    I am making a wild guess here - the cost of OC on Marina would be comparable (or possibly even less?) to PH on Crystal (if one doesn’t drink).

     

    I will be surprised if you are right, but I will do my best to calculate the numbers and report by tomorrow 

  8. 2 hours ago, Paulchili said:

    docmark,

    Thank you for your comprehensive review.

    What cabin were you in on the Symphony and how did the per diem costs compare (in comparable cabins)?

    TIA

    Thanks Paul, the reason I didn't do comparative cost is that we were in Oceania Suite both times on Marina , and in PH on Crystal, much smaller, but plenty of storage  space including a walk in closet. We were comfortable there except my wife didn't like TV location(side of bed instead of directly in front). I will look into requested calculations after I retrieve the last Marina cruise cost. Also will have to factor in liquor cost when we do a comparison (My wife was not without a glass of red wine in her hand at any time !!)

     

    ---Another side note on Raspberries, since I know you are partial to them: I am also very fond of Raspberries and a little less of Blackberries. So every morning at breakfast I would ask for a bowl of them , and they served it promptly .They were very fresh .

    I also agree with you on Croissant "superior quality" on Marina 

  9. Our first Crystal Ocean cruise was 1/5/20 on Symphony for 8 days. Prior to that our last 2 Ocean cruises were on Marina , last one November 2019 for 12 days(our only experience with Oceania).

     

    First of all I like to state that we enjoyed both lines and would not have any problems cruising on either with desirable itinerary.

     

    One area  that I feel there is NO contest is quality/ quantity of entertainment : Crystal wins "hands down" 

    Food :  

      Breakfast  : Service slow at GDR ,  excellent Croissant and lamb chops GDR.  Very prompt and attentive service at Waterside

     Lunch : GDR closed EVERY Port day, Waterside closed only ONE port day.  "Buffet" lunches were very good at both ships. small advantage to Marketplace on  Symphony.

     Dinner:

        --Only one dinner at GDR, poor experience, there were 6 of us ,"lead" waiter 's English very poor, we had difficulty understanding him and he apparently didn't understand us well: one wrong entre and one wrong desert. Quality/taste of food also mediocre. Waterside BTO night  dinner was excellent , had dinner there one other night,  service was great, food was "just OK".      ------       Waterside  "wins" over GDR

       --"Buffet dinner"  No buffet service at Symphony,  which I feel it is  a definite shortcoming (further comments later) . Very good experience at Terrace  dinners. The Grill station excellent with choices for meat, shrimp, fish, and Lobster. Definite advantage to Marina

    ---Specialty restaurants :  Overall excellent food BOTH ships. Service also great on all restaurants. The one advantage on Marina was ease of reservations: there were 12 of us travelling together in November 2019, and our butler made multiple reservations, at the exact requested time,  in Jacques, Red Ginger and Toscana. We ate only once at Polo. On the other hand we had significant difficulty securing "additional" reservations at Umi Uma and Prego.( We ate dinner once at Silk at the requested time and we enjoyed it ). It is possible that One factor for the difficulty was the length of the cruise (8 days)

    ---Other venues:  Waves and Trident comparable. Barista and Bistro somewhat similar, but Bistro provides service till 11:00 pm, while Barista closes at 6 pm.  

    --SPACE/LOUNGES : Definite advantage Symphony. 

    We were very impressed with overall level of good service at both ships, but give slight edge to Symphony.

    I feel converting Marketplace to "Brazilian" food at night is a mistake. We did not eat there , but "made rounds" there 3 evenings, and even though capacity is reduced, only one night the place was more than 1/2 full. Also in conversation with 2 couples who had eaten there , we were told they were disappointed .Also my impression /memory of comments on Cruise critic leads me to believe more people have same opinion.

    We will probably be cruising primarily on Crystal in future ( while hoping specialty reservation issue improves on our next cruise on Symphony in August, which is 13 days long) . My wife and I are both red wine drinkers and the "inclusive" factor is definitely a positive influence. Also the very excellent level of entertainment is a huge factor for us. However I can easily understand people who don't indulge in alcoholic drinks, and are not much interested in entertainment, to prefer Oceania .One thing I will miss, like Bitob  is the spacious suites on Marina!!  

     

    (I will be glad to address any areas I did not cover with detail) 

     

    • Like 1
×
×
  • Create New...