And this is exactly the reason I tell people you won't know if you like the food unless you try it yourself. 😂
I am the opposite, really dislike Dragon Lady, I find it too dark a dreary and the food is not to my regular Asian tastes.
On the other hand I love to dine at Angelo's every other night, rotating with the Waterfront.
I rarely eat at any type of restaurants or even pub meals normally. So I enjoy the whole experience of sitting down and being served. Here comes those rose coloured glasses again! 😎 I confess I like the food on P&O and yes of course there will always be better options on other ships but I don't choose a cruise based on whether I am in love the food. I choose it for the price, the convenience of ports, the itineraries.... however I think it's perfectly fine for others to choose their cruises heavily based on food!
My point is, yes there is a point, that all opinions on the food are valid however not all are relevant to your individual preference.