NaPali Coast excursion

[PBJ123]

Hello. We are sailing on the PoA on May 20th, and I have managed to plan just about every detail of our upcoming cruise using the fantastic information from this board. I just have one question left. Do I book my own NaPali Coast tour with Captain Andy's (and therefore have to deal with a rental car) or just book the ship's excursion, which seems similar? Thanks in advance for your ideas!

[Cruise_More_Often]

I hope you get a good answer. Unfortunately for us there's no Na Pali shore excursion listed for our sailing in January, so I guess the ship doesn't do winter excursions there. Thank you so much for your suggestion about Captain Andy's excursion. The sunset dinner sail looks wonderful, and I think we'll go ahead and book that one. We were planning on renting a car anyway.