Amber Cove Ocean Cabana or pool cabana?

[cjnix29]

trying to decide which one to rent. the water here doesn't look like typical Caribbean water, the beautiful blue, so thinking maybe we won't enjoy it as much? But do like the idea of getting the water sport rental included. Pool seems like it may be just a loud party, not sure if that is what I want either, but would at least be a place to go of our own. Thoughts for pros and cons? Thanks!

[reerun25]

The pool cabanas are sold out for my cruise, but there are a few ocean ones available. My issue is that there will be 12 of us, and the ocean ones say they are for 8 people. Not an issue as far as actual use, doubt there will be more than 5 or 6 that stay to use it, just wondering if everyone may be able to come and go, to like drop off bags or items, or will they have to have a wristband and they check to see if you have one to get access to the ocean cabana area.