Which tour to Buck Island?

[SRF]

I posted this in the St. Croix section, but got NO answers in 24 hours, so figured I could get some answers here.

 

We will be in St. Croix in April.

 

Looking at doing a snorkeling trip to Buck Island.

 

Choices seem to be the cruise line or Big Beard's (feel free to suggest other ones).

 

Big Beard's is a bit more with transport to their location, but is a longer tour and includes lunch.

 

Suggestions?  Comments?

[SRF]

Wow, no answers here either.

[lambstew]

We have done Big Beards twice.  We signed up for the full day - and the first time, it rained really hard after our Buck Island snorkeling so they said they could not start the barbeque in the rain, so they refunded the difference between a full day and half day tour in cash.  Arranged transportation for us and took great care of us.  The second time, it was a full day, the snorkeling was great and the beach barbeque was great!  I highly recommend Big Beards. 

 

[SRF]

Thanks.

 

No problem with transport and timing?