Which itinerary is best?

[thesnoopster2]

Trying to decide on which one to do, the circle around Cuba with Cozumel, Grand Cayman, Jamaica, OR the east side route Dominican Republic, Pueto Rico, Virgin Islands.  I've been to Cozumel before, but didn't do much there, but at the same time I'm not sure about going to US destinations, even though they are not US states.  I will be traveling with a 4 year old and one other adult. 

 

What's the pro/cons of each itinerary??

[JT1962]

Both itineraries are good. I have been to all of the ports listed more than once and enjoyed them all. I would suggest doing some research on the excursions that are available through the cruise line and researching the ports on this & other cruise websites and TripAdvisor to see what excursions / sites may interest you most.
 

You would probably be limited on some of the more popular excursions with a 4 year old due to age restrictions. You can always do a beach day in most of the ports.