Miracle vs Valor

[mirage2u]

I'm torn between these 2 ships for a March 2007 sailing. Can anyone help?

 

The Miracle looks like a much more interesting and fun ship. I like the ficitional character them better then the americana theme.

 

The Miracle leaves out of Tampa which is about 30 mins from where I live. The Valor leaves out of Miami which is 4 1/2 hours away.

 

They both have Western itineraries but the Valor has a better itinerary, grand cayman, roatan, belize, costa maya. The Miracle goes to cozumel, grand cayman, belize and costa maya. I been to all except for costa maya. I loved roatan, it was one the best island i've ever been to. I don't espically like Belize.

 

Has anyone done both and have a preference?

[FliLady]

I just got off the Miracle a few weeks ago and loved the ship and the itinerary. Came home and booked the Valor for August!! The Valor is a bigger ship with a different layout and very few obstructed balconies. The Miracle was beautiful and I had no complaints. Either way, I don't think you can go wrong!