I have not been on the Magic yet, but my husband and I board it next Saturday. I booked it because it is supposed to be exactly like the Dream, which we loved. We chose it because it has the best spa area of any of the Carnival ships. We get a spa cabin and thoroughly enjoy everything it has from the thassolopia pool to the heated loungers that look out at the ocean to every other quiet, peaceful spot in the spa. It is a totally relaxing place and as someone said, if you don’t book a spa cabin, buy the day passes. Completely worth it !!