Jump to content

harryw

Members
  • Posts

    1,518
  • Joined

Posts posted by harryw

  1. 4 hours ago, orchestrapal said:

     

    We found the musicians on VO to be most cordial and we actually became friendly with many of them. We have not had  an experience like your’s on O but will try harder next time. We still enjoy both lines and are booked on both in the coming months.

    We took our first Viking Cruise last year (Sea), and found that they had the BEST ship band we’ve ever heard. The duo lead singers were superb and played numerous genres.

    The backup musicians were excellent.

    • Like 1
  2. 17 minutes ago, roothy123 said:

    Well, I was on the same Viking cruise and it was a younger crowd than usual, perhaps because it was Christmas to New Years. It was definitely a fun crowd.  That changes the whole experience. I agree that the music was good, but it seemed very similar to what Oceania has.  I think this cruise had some enhancements from our one on Viking a year ago. It was a totally awesome cruise. But I think in general that Viking is more low keyed than Oceania, with a slightly older crowd, and fewer activities.  (My husband loves the activities; I can get by without them.) I think both lines have about the same quality in food (with O having more options), service and music. Oceania seems a little less expensive, but of course it's hard to compare prices as V includes certain things in the price and O includes other things.  We enjoy both lines about the same, so choose mostly by itinerary. 

    Roothy-

     

    As we are leaving for our first HAL cruise in 2 weeks, on the Nieuw Statendam, how would you compare HAL food with Oceania?

  3. 2 hours ago, Dr. Cocktail said:

    I have now done O, V, and Azamara as well as Ponant.

     

    The math is pretty simple ... as you go up the "food chain", the age becomes older. There is an absolute and definite correlation between the price paid and the age of the crowd.

     

    My partner and I are in my mid 50's and literally just got off Viking Sun. While we had a great time, it was most definitely NOT a good fit for us.

     

    There is a bizarre disconnect between the products offered by the upper end cruise lines and what (slightly!) ageing and affluent cruisers want. While we both have post-grad degrees (one of them including music performance!), we don't want endless string ensembles with deadly Norwegian selections, lame main theater shows and an overall lack of energy.

     

    When will the cruise lines learn that as we age,  we don't want to be in an extremely elegant mortuary?! Growing up in the 60's (and I think the primary target audience grew up in the 50's!),  I/we want the Temptations, the Beatles, the Four Tops, Carol King and James Taylor, Billy Joel and Bruce Springsteen!!! 

     

    Again, this is from someone who had an opera subscription for 28 years!!!

     

    A long way of saying ... try Azamara or ... the Haven or The Yacht Club!

    “When will the cruise lines learn that as we age,  we don't want to be in an extremely elegant mortuary?! Growing up in the 60's (and I think the primary target audience grew up in the 50's!),  I/we want the Temptations, the Beatlesthe Four Tops, Carol King and James TaylorBilly Joel and Bruce Springsteen!!!”

    I don’t have an answer but just want to

    wholeheartedly echo this sentiment. I am 65 and having been mostly on Oceania the past 5 years, the above mentioned music is my favorite too. Unfortunately, the “covers” done at production shows were cringeworthy.

    But we are sailing on HAL for the first time this month, and their new Rolling Stone Rock Room sounds promising! 

     

  4. 24 minutes ago, Travrat said:

    Since you usually sail on Oceania I hope you will not be disappointed with the food on HAL. I have sailed HAL 7 times over the past 20 years and Oceania 3 times in the past 7 years. I find the food and service on Oceania far superior to HAL but the entertainment on HAL is better. HAL used to have great food and service but I personally have seen a decline in both recently. I hope you have a nice experience on the N Statendam

     

    Someone posted menus on the maiden voyage thread. The MDR breakfast seems better than the Oceania counterpart. And we like to start the day with a leisurely hot

     breakfast. So that is promising, Though the Oceania specialty restaurant menus are more enticing.

×
×
  • Create New...